The High Priestess of Blood: Deception, Delusion, and the Yerba Buena Cult Killings

---

The Gods Who Created the High Priestess of Blood

---

In 1963, the village of Yerbabuena, nestled deep in the mountains of Tamaulipas, Mexico, was a world unto itself. Home to about 50 souls, it was a community cut off by geography and trapped by the crushing weight of poverty and illiteracy.¹ Its isolation was so profound that it became a petri dish for a social contagion, a place where the lines between faith, desperation, and madness could blur into nonexistence. This is the story of how a crude con about hidden treasure, perpetrated by two charismatic grifters, spiraled into a vortex of ritualistic murder, vampirism, and absolute terror.

At the center of this storm were Santos and Cayetano Hernández, brothers who saw in the villagers’ desperation an opportunity for exploitation.¹ But the true catalyst for the horror was the young woman they enlisted in their scheme: a prostitute named Magdalena Solís. In Yerbabuena, Solís would be transformed from a pawn in a simple scam into a self-proclaimed goddess who believed her divinity could only be sustained by the most terrible price imaginable: human blood.¹

The nightmare that unfolded in the caves surrounding the village would remain a secret, buried in the mountains, were it not for the courage of one 14-year-old boy. In May 1963, Sebastián Guerrero’s youthful curiosity led him to witness a horror that defied belief, setting in motion a chain of events that would expose the cult’s depravity, but only at the cost of his own life.¹

---

Dramatis Personae: The Faces of Yerbabuena

---

To understand the complex web of relationships and roles within the cult, the following provides a reference for the key individuals involved in the Yerbabuena killings.

Name	Role	Fate
Magdalena Solís	The “High Priestess of Blood”; Prostitute turned cult leader	Arrested; Sentenced to 50 years in prison
Eleazar Solís	Magdalena’s brother and pimp; Cult enforcer	Arrested; Sentenced to 50 years in prison
Santos Hernández	Co-founder of the cult; “Prophet”	Killed while resisting arrest
Cayetano Hernández	Co-founder of the cult; “Prophet”	Murdered by a cult member prior to the police raid
Sebastián Guerrero	14-year-old witness	Murdered by the cult; his body was later discovered
Luis Martínez	Police officer who investigated Guerrero’s claim	Murdered by the cult; his body was later discovered
Unnamed Dissenters	The first victims; cult members who tried to leave	Lynched on Solís’s orders
The Villagers	Cult followers and participants	Several killed in a shootout; survivors arrested

Background of the Victims: The Lost Voices of Yerbabuena

---

In the fog of such extreme violence, the identities of the victims often become secondary to the monstrous acts committed against them. But the story of the Yerbabuena cult is defined by those it consumed, individuals whose defiance, curiosity, or sense of duty led them into the heart of the darkness.

The Catalyst: Sebastián Guerrero

Sebastián Guerrero was a 14-year-old boy living in a world circumscribed by the mountains and the myths that populated them.¹ Like many in his village, he was likely aware of the rumors of hidden treasure in the nearby caves, a fantasy fueled by the Hernández brothers’ promises.³ One night in May 1963, drawn by strange lights and the sound of chanting from a place that was usually deserted after dark, his curiosity overcame his fear. What he witnessed in that cave—a ritual murder in progress—shattered his reality.

In a display of incredible bravery, Sebastián ran 25 kilometers through the night to the nearest town, Villagrán, to report what he had seen.¹ He arrived exhausted and in shock, babbling to disbelieving officers about a “group of murderers, seized by ecstasy, gathered to drink human blood”.¹ His plea for help was a desperate cry from a world the police could not comprehend, and it would ultimately seal his fate.

The Protector: Officer Luis Martínez

While most of his colleagues dismissed Sebastián’s story as the fantasy of a frightened child, one officer, Luis Martínez, felt a professional and moral obligation to investigate.¹ He saw something in the boy’s terror that demanded to be taken seriously. In an act of conscientious police work, he offered to escort Sebastián back to Yerbabuena to see the site of the alleged crime.

This decision was a fatal act of duty. Officer Martínez walked willingly into the cult’s domain, an outsider representing a system of law and order that had no meaning there. He and Sebastián were never seen alive again. The later discovery of Martínez’s dismembered body, his heart crudely carved from his chest, was a brutal testament to the cult’s savagery and their complete rejection of the world beyond their mountain enclave.¹

The First to Fall: The Dissenters

The first people to die at the hands of the Yerbabuena cult were not sacrifices to a bloodthirsty goddess, but victims of a more terrestrial evil: control. The records show that two members of the cult, who remain unnamed, became “fed up with the sexual abuse” and expressed their desire to leave the community.¹ For the Hernández brothers and the newly empowered Magdalena Solís, this was an existential threat.

These dissenters were living proof that the spell could be broken, and their departure could expose the entire operation as a fraud. Solís, in her first true act as a leader, decreed that they be sacrificed. They were lynched by their fellow cult members.¹ These murders were not yet ritualistic; they were tactical, a cold-blooded message to the remaining followers that the only way out of Yerbabuena was death. The violence began not as an act of faith, but as a pragmatic tool of terror. Only later would this terror be given a name and a theology.

The Sacrificed

After the initial purge, the murders became institutionalized. The victims of the subsequent “blood rituals” were also drawn from within the cult’s own ranks, always identified as “dissenting members.¹ These were not random outsiders but neighbors, and perhaps even family, who were systematically eliminated to enforce conformity and deepen the collective trauma. Their deaths served a dual purpose: they fed the goddess’s supposed thirst for blood while simultaneously reinforcing the absolute, life-or-death power of the High Priestess over her flock.

---

The Crime: A Chronology of Horror

---

The descent of Yerbabuena into a blood-soaked abattoir was not instantaneous. It was a gradual process, a step-by-step erosion of reality that began with a simple lie and ended in a shared psychosis.

Part 1: The Con (Late 1962)

In late 1962, Santos and Cayetano Hernández arrived in Yerbabuena.¹ They were petty criminals who understood the alchemy of turning desperation into profit. They surveyed the impoverished, isolated community and saw a captive audience. Proclaiming themselves prophets, they spun a tale of “powerful and exiled Inca gods” who had hidden immense treasures in the local caves.¹ In exchange for absolute loyalty, financial tribute, and sexual favors from members of all genders, the brothers promised the gods would reveal this wealth and usher in an era of prosperity.

The choice of “Inca gods” was, on its face, absurd. The Inca Empire was centered thousands of miles away in Peru and had no historical or cultural connection to Mexico. The fact that this glaring falsehood was not immediately questioned speaks volumes about the profound vacuum in which the villagers lived. Their isolation was not merely geographical; it was epistemological. Lacking the basic framework of outside knowledge to challenge the conmen’s claims, they were vulnerable to any narrative that offered a glimmer of hope. The success of this initial, clumsy deception was a direct measure of their desperation and their disconnection from the world.

Part 2: The “Goddess” (Early 1963)

Months passed, and the promised treasures failed to materialize. The villagers’ faith, their most valuable currency, began to wane.¹ Facing a failing enterprise, the Hernández brothers devised a new strategy to reinvigorate their flock. They traveled to the city of Monterrey in search of prostitutes who could play a role in a new, more theatrical phase of their scam. There, they met Magdalena Solís and her brother and pimp, Eleazar.¹

Returning to Yerbabuena, the brothers orchestrated a dramatic ritual in one of the caves. Using a “smoke screen trick,” they presented Magdalena Solís to the assembled villagers as the reincarnation of the powerful Aztec goddess Cōātlīcue, the mother of gods, a formidable and fearsome deity associated with creation and destruction.¹ This was a brilliant and sinister strategic pivot.

Where the foreign “Inca” myth was failing, the Aztec narrative held a primal, cultural resonance. It tapped into a deeper, more violent stream of pre-Columbian mythology known to the region. The shift from a simple treasure hunt to the resurrection of a bloodthirsty goddess transformed the failing con into something far more potent and dangerous. It provided the theological architecture for the horrors that were to come.

Part 3: The Purge and the Ritual (March-May 1963)

With Solís installed as a living deity, the power dynamic shifted irrevocably. She began to believe in her own divinity, a delusion reinforced daily by the desperate worship of her followers. This symbiotic relationship—her followers needed a god, and she needed to be one—created a feedback loop of escalating madness. When the two dissenters tried to leave, Solís’s order to lynch them cemented her absolute authority.¹

Soon after, bored with the simple orgies and tributes, Solís decreed that the goddess required a more profound form of worship: human sacrifice. She devised the “blood ritual“.¹ The process was a study in collective depravity. A victim, always a dissenting member, was brought before the cult. The entire congregation would then participate in their destruction, brutally beating, burning, and mutilating them.¹ As the victim bled to death, their blood was collected in a chalice.

It was then mixed with chicken blood and narcotics—typically marijuana or peyote—and served. Solís drank first, followed by the Hernández brothers, and then the rest of the cult members.¹ The theological justification was that blood was the “only food the gods can ingest,” and Cōātlīcue needed it to maintain her eternal youth.¹ This carnage continued for six weeks, during which at least four more people were murdered in this fashion, with some rituals culminating in the victim’s heart being ripped from their chest.¹

Part 4: The Final Witness (Night of May 1963)

It was during one of these horrific rituals that 14-year-old Sebastián Guerrero approached the caves, drawn by the strange lights and sounds.^{1 Peeking inside, he saw the unthinkable: his neighbors, his community, engaged in a ritual of torture and murder. Terrified, he fled into the night, beginning his desperate 25-kilometer run to the police station in Villagrán, carrying with him a story that no sane person could be expected to believe.1}

---

The Investigation: Unearthing the Nightmare

---

The initial police response in Villagrán was one of weary skepticism. A wild-eyed boy rambling about vampires and blood-drinking murderers was easily dismissed.¹ But Officer Luis Martínez saw past the fantastical claims to the genuine terror in Sebastián Guerrero’s eyes. His decision to accompany the boy back to Yerbabuena was the first official step in an investigation that would quickly spiral into a military operation.

When days passed with no word from either Martínez or Guerrero, the police in Villagrán were forced to confront a horrifying possibility. The boy’s story had not been a delusion. Dismayed and fearing for their colleague’s life, they escalated the matter, contacting the Mexican army for assistance.¹

On May 31, 1963, a joint force of police officers and soldiers descended on Yerbabuena.¹ They found and arrested Magdalena and Eleazar Solís at a nearby farm; both were reportedly under the influence of marijuana.¹ The raid brought a chaotic and bloody end to the cult’s leadership. Santos Hernández was shot and killed while resisting arrest. His brother, Cayetano, was already dead, having been murdered by a paranoid cult member named Jesús Rubio, who believed a piece of the high priest’s body would grant him protection.¹ Many of the remaining cultists had barricaded themselves inside the ritual caves and were killed in shootouts with the authorities.¹

The true scope of the horror was revealed in the days that followed. Near the farm where the Solís siblings were captured, investigators unearthed the dismembered bodies of Sebastián Guerrero and Officer Luis Martínez. As a final, gruesome signature, Martínez’s heart had been removed.¹ Subsequent searches of the caves yielded the mutilated corpses of six more people.¹ The official body count stood at eight, though authorities suspected the total number of victims could be as high as 15.¹

The Theories: The Psychology of a Killer Goddess

With the perpetrators captured or killed, the investigation shifted from “who” to “why.” The events at Yerbabuena were not the work of a single deranged individual, but a complex interplay of cynical manipulation, severe psychosis, and profound social vulnerability.

A Trifecta of Malice, Madness, and Manipulation

The official analysis points to three distinct but interconnected criminal profiles. The Hernández brothers were the architects of the initial deception. They were not believers but classic con artists, motivated by greed and a desire for power. Their crime was one of cynical exploitation, preying on the weak for personal gain.¹

Magdalena Solís, however, represented something far more complex and dangerous. Recruited from a background of poverty and sexual exploitation, she was handed a position of immense power.¹ This power appears to have ignited a latent and severe psychological condition.

Psychiatric profiles described her as suffering from a “theological psychosis,” characterized by religious and grandiose delusions, as well as extreme sexual sadism and vampirism.^{4 She represents a rare documented case of a female serial killer who was simultaneously organized in her methods, visionary in her twisted ideology, and hedonistic in her motivations, deriving pleasure from the acts of torture and murder.1}

Group Dynamics: The Perfect Storm of Vulnerability

The evil of the cult’s leaders could not have flourished without the fertile ground of Yerbabuena’s unique social conditions. Several factors created a perfect storm of vulnerability:

Extreme Isolation:

The village’s physical and informational separation from the outside world prevented any reality checks on the leaders’ claims.¹

Poverty and Desperation:

The community was so destitute that they were willing to cling to any promise of salvation, no matter how outlandish.¹

Illiteracy:

The inability of the villagers to read or critically analyze information made them highly susceptible to manipulation and charismatic authority.¹

Fear and Coercion:

After the first murders of the dissenters, the primary motivator for many was no longer faith, but terror. Participation in the rituals became a means of survival.¹

This environment fostered a collective psychological breakdown, a phenomenon known as folie à plusieurs, or shared psychosis. Magdalena Solís’s delusions became the community’s reality. Her followers, trapped by fear and a desperate need to believe, became active participants in her madness, their complicity reinforcing her divine status and validating the escalating violence.

---

The Aftermath and Enduring Questions

---

The legal conclusion to the Yerbabuena nightmare felt starkly inadequate. Magdalena and her brother Eleazar were convicted, but only for two of the murders—those of Sebastián Guerrero and Luis Martínez. For these crimes, they were each sentenced to 50 years in prison.¹

The reason for these limited convictions was a final, chilling testament to the cult’s power: a wall of silence. The surviving cult members, the very people who had participated in the beatings and the blood rituals, refused to testify against the Solís siblings regarding the other murders.¹ This silence was likely born of a complex mix of emotions. Fear of reprisal and lingering loyalty may have played a part, but it is also plausible that their refusal was an act of profound psychological self-preservation.

To testify would have meant verbally admitting their own complicity in the butchery of their neighbors. It would have forced them to confront the unbearable truth that the divine belief system for which they had killed and debased themselves was a complete and utter lie. For people who had lost everything, silence may have been the only shield they had left against a truth too monstrous to bear.

The story of Magdalena Solís and the Yerbabuena cult leaves us with a number of unsettling questions about the nature of belief, the power of manipulation, and the darkness that can fester in the isolated corners of the world.

Works cited

1. Magdalena Solís – Wikipedia, accessed August 17, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magdalena_Sol%C3%ADs
2. Short Suck #19 – Magdalena Solís: The High Priestess of Blood – ART19, accessed August 17, 2025, https://art19.com/shows/timesuck-premium/episodes/cc9c2cdf-02c5-433c-b6ff-65585d291180
3. Ep 40: HAUNTED: The Cult of Magdalena Solis: The High Priestess of Blood – JioSaavn, accessed August 17, 2025, https://www.jiosaavn.com/shows/ep-40-haunted-the-cult-of-magdalena-solis-the-high-priestess-of-blood/w4TVPx3Bseo_
4. Magdalena Solís – Wikipedia, la enciclopedia libre, accessed August 17, 2025, https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magdalena_Sol%C3%ADs
5. Magdalena Solís: La sacerdotisa de la sangre en México | Historias Criminales – YouTube, accessed August 17, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yUMuwY2wDJI
6. Magdalena Solis, la prêtresse du sang : quand des sacrifices étaient pratiqués sur des fermiers mexicains – RTBF, accessed August 17, 2025, https://www.rtbf.be/article/magdalena-solis-la-pretresse-du-sang-quand-des-sacrifices-etaient-pratiques-sur-des-fermiers-mexicains-11328514
7. Who was Magdalena Solís? Paranormal Cults, Human Sacrifice and Elizabeth Bathory. – Apple Podcasts, accessed August 17, 2025, https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/who-was-magdalena-sol%C3%ADs-paranormal-cults-human-sacrifice/id1704031504?i=1000646823320
8. The Rise of Magdalena Solís, The High Priestess of Blood – Apple Podcasts, accessed August 17, 2025, https://podcasts.apple.com/pt/podcast/the-rise-of-magdalena-sol%C3%ADs-the-high-priestess-of-blood/id1788226464?i=1000685033334