The Lonely Hearts Killers: Finding Love in the Classifieds, Finding Death Instead

I. The Architects of Misery: A Look at Our Lonely Hearts Killers

If you thought navigating the digital dating landscape today was perilous, take a charming little trip back to the late 1940s. A time when finding companionship through a newspaper ad was all the rage, and for a select few unfortunate souls, it was also the express lane to an early grave. Enter Raymond Fernandez and Martha Beck, a pair who earned the rather on-the-nose moniker of “The Lonely Hearts Killers.” Their story isn’t some quaint historical footnote; it’s a masterclass in exploiting vulnerability, a grim ballet of deceit, manipulation, and brutal violence set against a backdrop of post-war societal yearning.

Forget Hallmark romance; this is a tapestry woven from con artistry, a level of codependent pathology that would make therapists weep, and a body count that served as a stark warning against trusting strangers who claim to have a “way with women.” Fernandez, the supposed charismatic Voodoo practitioner, and Beck, his fiercely loyal, impossibly jealous, and terrifyingly effective accomplice, saw the lonely hearts columns not as a path to connection, but as a remarkably efficient target list. Their twisted saga peels back the veneer of post-war optimism to reveal a chilling intersection of desperate longing and lethal intent.

Let’s pull back the curtain on the individuals who decided preying on the desperate was a solid career choice.

A. Raymond Martinez Fernandez: The “Voodoo” Charmer

Born in Hawaii, raised in Connecticut, Raymond Fernandez apparently decided the American Dream wasn’t for him. He packed his bags for Spain, married, had some kids (accounts vary, but let’s just say he was fertile before he was fatal), and then promptly disappeared from their lives. Charming.

The Second World War saw him dabble in British intelligence – a brief flirtation with something vaguely respectable, if you squint hard enough. He even got a commendation for his loyalty. Irony, meet history.

His real turning point, or perhaps his excuse, came on the voyage back to the States. A bit of industrial-grade cranial trauma courtesy of a falling hatch transformed him from a reportedly agreeable fellow into… well, into Raymond Fernandez, serial con artist and murderer. This head injury, the kind that requires plating and likely rearranged his frontal lobe’s filing system, is often cited as the moment his impulse control packed its bags and left town. Sudden rage? Check. Chronic headaches? Check. Balding? Apparently so, necessitating a toupee – a detail that somehow makes the whole thing simultaneously sadder and more pathetic.

Post-hospitalization, a stint in the clink for petty theft introduced him to the wondrous world of Vodou. Or rather, his version of it. He became convinced he was an oungan, a priest blessed with supernatural mojo, specifically an irresistible power over women. Now, let’s be clear: authentic Vodou isn’t about using dark magic to pick up lonely ladies. It’s a complex spiritual system.

Fernandez’s embrace of it reads less like genuine faith and more like adopting a creepy pick-up artist persona with added mysticism. The user article mentions him devouring texts on “sacrifice and torture,” which, again, isn’t standard Vodou fare. This strongly suggests he was cherry-picking the darkest, most sensationalized aspects to fuel his inflated ego and justify his predatory behavior. Voodoo as a manipulation tool? Apparently, anything goes when you’re building a brand.

B. Martha Jule Beck: The Jealous Enforcer

Martha Beck. Born in Florida, faced a childhood that sounds like a Dickensian novel minus the orphans and plus the alleged brotherly abuse. Being overweight earned her the charming moniker of “fatso,” which, coupled with familial trauma, likely did wonders for her self-esteem. She found solace, predictably, in romance novels and movies – a retreat into fantasy that would prove disastrously enabling later.

A brief, odd episode involves running away with a young Truman Capote. One day. They were found. One can only imagine the conversations.

Despite the hardship, Martha actually managed to become a nurse. The user article claims valedictorian, which isn’t definitively confirmed by external sources, but she was by all accounts competent, even rising to superintendent. A brief professional success before her personal life imploded.

Then came the pregnancies. Two, out of wedlock, in a time when that wasn’t exactly celebrated. The first father reportedly either refused to marry her or attempted suicide – a truly inspiring level of commitment either way. She fled back to Florida, spun a tear-jerking tale of being a war widow (complete with a newspaper feature!), and had a daughter. The second pregnancy resulted in a hasty, six-month marriage to a bus driver. Another child, another failed relationship.

Feeling adrift, isolated, and apparently still craving the fictional romance she read about, Martha turned to the lonely hearts ads in 1947. And into the digital-dating-from-hell landscape she stepped. The cumulative effect of their respective traumas is blindingly obvious. Fernandez’s head injury likely scrambled his moral compass, allowing him to lean into a Voodoo-fueled power fantasy. Beck’s lifetime of rejection and abuse left her desperate for the kind of all-consuming affection found in her novels. She was a target perfectly primed for Fernandez’s brand of manipulative “love.” Her nursing career, her desire to help humanity? Apparently no match for a con artist with a toupee and claims of supernatural charm.

II. An Unholy Union: When Lonely Met Lethal

Their meet-cute involved a newspaper ad and Fernandez requesting a lock of Martha’s hair for a Voodoo ritual to make himself irresistible. Because nothing says “romance” like using alleged dark magic on a stranger’s hair sample.

Their first meeting in Florida was reportedly awkward, with Fernandez apparently surprised by Martha’s size (she’d conveniently left that out of her ad). But size, it seems, was no impediment to instant, intense, and utterly twisted intimacy. Martha, drowning in longing and susceptible to every romantic trope she’d ever read, was hooked. Marriage and financial security were promised – the classic con artist bait.

Martha’s commitment was swift and, frankly, horrifying. She abandoned her two young children at a Salvation Army shelter. Let that sink in. Children. Abandoned. For a guy who asked for her hair sample. If that’s not a red flag, the flag factory has burned down.

Upon arriving at Fernandez’s New York abode, he laid out his business model: he was a “lonely hearts” con artist, fleecing vulnerable women. Martha’s reaction? Enthralled. She eagerly signed up to be his partner in crime. Their strategy was simple and effective: Martha would pose as Raymond’s sister. This added a veneer of respectability, making them seem less threatening and more like a well-meaning, if slightly odd, sibling pair. Lonely women, often widows or spinsters, let them in, literally and figuratively.

The dark heart of their partnership was Martha’s jealousy. It wasn’t just a personality quirk; it was a homicidal trigger. If she suspected Fernandez had genuine feelings for, or, heaven forbid, slept with their victims, her rage would explode. This wasn’t just directed at the poor woman; Fernandez often bore the brunt of it too. This volatile dynamic frequently escalated their operation from simple fraud to outright murder. Her possessiveness wasn’t born of healthy love, but a desperate, pathological need to own him entirely, a need likely fueled by her past rejections.

Their “sister” routine was, in a grim way, brilliant. It exploited societal expectations and trust. Who would suspect a brother-sister duo? It capitalized on the trust women might place in another woman, making them drop their guard. It was a calculated move, turning a social convention into a weapon.

Table 1: A Timeline of Terrors

Dec 17, 1914	Raymond Fernandez Born	The future “Lonely Hearts” killer enters the world.
May 6, 1920	Martha Beck Born	The future “Lonely Hearts” killer enters the world (and faces immediate societal judgment).
Early 1930s	Fernandez in Spain	Marriage, kids, abandonment. Standard pre-killing biography stuff.
WWII	Fernandez with British Intelligence	A brief, ironic detour into doing something vaguely useful.
Post-WWII	Fernandez’s Head Injury	The alleged turning point from “agreeable fellow” to “serial con artist.”
c. 1946	Fernandez’s Prison Stint	Introduced to his version of Voodoo and the idea of having “power over women.”
1942	Beck Graduates Nursing School	Momentary professional success before diving headfirst into pathological devotion.
Mid-1940s	Beck’s Pregnancies & Brief Marriage	A series of personal disappointments leading to lonely hearts ads.
Oct-Nov 1947	Murder of Jane Thompson (probable)	Fernandez’s potential first solo act of fatal financial planning in Spain. Timing debated, but definitely pre-Beck.
Dec 1947	Fernandez and Beck Meet	The fateful connection via lonely hearts ad and a hair sample request.
Early 1948	Beck Joins Fernandez	Abandons her children. Becomes partner in crime, poses as his “sister.”
1948	Target: Esther Henne (alleged)	A woman who saw through the charade and escaped. Details fuzzy, but a rare win for common sense.
Aug 1948	Murder of Myrtle Young	Death by dubious means – either drugged on a bus or a cerebral hemorrhage after complaining to police. Pick your poison.
Jan 1949	Murder of Janet Fay	Beck’s jealousy erupts, leading to a hammer and strangulation. Body buried in a cellar.
Feb 28, 1949	Murders of Delphine Downing and Rainelle Downing	Drugging, shooting, and the horrific drowning of a child. The act that finally got them caught.
Mar 1, 1949	Arrest	Busted in Michigan thanks to nosy (and thankfully, concerned) neighbors.
Summer 1949	Trial in New York	The media circus descends. Insanity defense rejected.
Aug 18/22, 1949	Conviction and Sentencing	Guilty as charged. Sentenced to death.
Mar 8, 1951	Execution	The electric chair at Sing Sing. A fitting, if grim, end.

III. A Roster of Ruined Lives: The Victims

The exact number of their victims remains murky, shrouded in the shifting sands of multiple confessions and investigative assumptions. Some put the count as high as twenty. We’ll stick to the ones we know about, or at least the ones with enough detail to be properly depressing.

A. Jane Thompson: The Spanish Getaway and a Forged Will

Jane Thompson, a recent divorcee looking for a good time that apparently involved Spain and Raymond Fernandez. Fernandez took her on a cruise, introduced her to his actual wife (awkward!), and then she turned up dead in a hotel room. No autopsy, swift burial by Spanish authorities. Convenient. Fernandez then returned to the U.S. and, using a forged will, took over her house, kicking out her elderly mother. A charming move, perfectly in line with his character. Sources generally agree this happened before he met Beck, establishing his predatory bonafides independently. The user article’s placement of this after their meeting seems… inaccurate, shall we say.

B. Esther Henne: The One Who Got Away

Esther Henne. Mentioned in the user article as a woman who married Fernandez (with Beck posing as his sister-in-law) but got suspicious and fled. Specifically, she apparently started asking questions about Jane Thompson’s convenient demise. Good for you, Esther. A survivor whose healthy skepticism likely saved her life. Shame there aren’t more details about her in other sources. A fleeting moment of sense in a narrative otherwise devoid of it.

C. Myrtle Young: A Cloudy Demise

Myrtle Young. Married Fernandez in Arkansas. Then things get hazy. Did he drug her with “horse sedatives,” put her on a bus, and she died in a hospital the next day? Or did she complain to Chicago police about being fleeced, Martha Beck winked at the desk sergeant (seriously, that’s a detail in a contemporary report), her complaint was dismissed, and she died soon after of a cerebral hemorrhage? Take your pick. Both scenarios are awful, but the conflicting accounts highlight the difficulty in pinning down the exact truth when dealing with these kinds of historical records. The police complaint scenario, with the wink, adds a layer of dark absurdity that’s hard to ignore.

D. Janet Fay: The New York Homicide

Janet Fay, a 66-year-old wealthy widow. Engaged to Fernandez. Beck, still playing the dutiful sister, moved in with them on Long Island. Big mistake, Janet. Beck’s jealousy, the toxic core of their relationship, boiled over. The user article suggests Beck caught Fay in bed with Fernandez – a likely trigger for the explosion. Beck, armed with a hammer, went to work. Fernandez finished the job with strangulation. Body in a trunk, buried in the cellar. Classic.

The family got suspicious when Fay disappeared. The user article leans into the detail that they received typed letters, which was odd because Fay didn’t own a typewriter. This is a compelling detail, and there’s some support for it, but the primary evidence of this exact trigger isn’t as robust as, say, police photos of the trunk and bloodstains. Regardless of the precise reason, Fay’s disappearance led to the investigation that brought them down in New York.

E. Delphine and Rainelle Downing: The Michigan Horror

After fleeing New York, they landed in Michigan with Delphine Downing and her two-year-old daughter, Rainelle. Delphine’s age varies in accounts (28 to 41 – pick one). The motive for her murder is also debated. The user article’s claim that Delphine got mad because Fernandez was bald and she discovered his toupee? While his baldness was real, this motive is not widely supported elsewhere. More likely scenarios involve Beck’s jealousy (again) or Delphine growing suspicious of their arrangement.

However it started, the ending is consistently grim. Martha drugged Delphine. Raymond shot her. Rainelle, witnessing this, started crying. Martha’s rage turned on the child. Accounts differ slightly (drowned in a basin, a bathtub, after a non-fatal strangulation), but the outcome is the same: a two-year-old murdered by drowning. One particularly repellent account even alleges sexual assault before the drowning. Both bodies ended up buried in the basement. It was the neighbors, bless their nosiness, who reported the Downings missing, leading police to the house and the grim discovery.

The escalation is undeniable. From potential opportunistic financial murder (Thompson) to increasingly jealousy-fueled, brutal killings involving a child. Beck’s pathological devotion and rage became the accelerant, pushing their crimes into truly repellent territory.

The discrepancies in the narratives – particularly around Myrtle Young’s death and Delphine Downing’s motive – aren’t just academic quibbles. They highlight how easily true crime stories can become muddled, filtered through sensational media, faulty memories, and incomplete records. Reconstructing a definitive history is often impossible; we’re left with fragmented, sometimes contradictory, pieces.

Table 2: The Unfortunate Cast of Victims

Victim Name	Age (Approx.)	How Met Killers	Location of Crime	Cause of Death/Outcome	Key Details/Discrepancies
Jane (Wilson) Thompson	Not specified	Fernandez’s overtures (likely pre-Beck).	Spain (hotel)	Found dead; no autopsy. Forged will.	Timing debated (pre or post Beck). Met Fernandez’s actual wife.
Esther Henne	Not specified	Married Fernandez via lonely hearts system (with Beck).	Pennsylvania	Fled; survived.	Became suspicious of Jane Thompson’s death. Details largely from user article, less external support.
Myrtle Young	Not specified	Married Fernandez.	Arkansas (marriage); Died en route/in Little Rock or Chicago.	Drugged, died comatose OR cerebral hemorrhage after police complaint.	Major conflicting accounts on cause and circumstances of death.
Janet Fay	66	Responded to lonely hearts ad, married Fernandez.	Long Island, NY	Bludgeoned by Beck, strangled by Fernandez.	Body in trunk/cellar. Family suspicious (disappearance/typed letters debate).
Delphine Downing	28-41 (varies)	Responded to lonely hearts ad.	Wyoming Township, Michigan	Drugged by Beck, shot by Fernandez.	Motive varies (baldness, jealousy, suspicion).
Rainelle Downing	2 years (or 21 months)	Present with mother.	Wyoming Township, Michigan	Drowned in bathtub/basin by Beck.	Witnessed mother’s fate, cried. Alleged non-fatal strangulation and sexual assault prior in some accounts.

IV. Preying on Loneliness: The Post-War Pickup Scene

The late 1940s weren’t just about victory parades and economic booms. They were also a time of significant social upheaval. People moved, traditional communities fractured, and finding connection could be tough. Enter the “Lonely Hearts” clubs and personal ads – the proto-Tinder of their day.

These platforms were a lifeline for people seeking companionship, a way to bridge geographical divides and social isolation. They weren’t new, but the post-war era, with its demographic shifts and lingering separation, saw their popularity explode. Studies from the time even note soldiers using these ads to find pen pals, a way to cope with being away from home.

Looking at old Lonely Hearts catalogs from the 1940s is like peering into a time capsule of vulnerability. You see ads, mostly from women, listing their names and addresses, openly stating their desire for a partner. It underscores the “plight of women” in that era, seeking connection in a rapidly changing world. Think of Betty Friedan’s later work on the dissatisfaction of housewives; the seeds of that yearning were already present, making these women particularly susceptible to promises of romance and security. These clubs weren’t just about dating; they reflected deeper societal needs for belonging and identity.

Fernandez and Beck didn’t invent the Lonely Hearts system, but they certainly perfected the art of exploiting it. They targeted the very people the system was designed to help – those openly advertising their vulnerability. Fernandez’s false charm and Beck’s “sister” act were designed to dismantle defenses built on hope. Their crimes were a grim, early warning about the dark side of mediated relationships, where trust is easily manipulated and false personas can lead to deadly outcomes. It’s a chilling precursor to modern online dating scams, proving that some dangers are timeless, regardless of the technology used.

V. The Wheels of “Justice”: Arrest, Trial, and Spectacle

Their killing spree came to an end in Michigan, thanks to neighbors who actually paid attention and reported Delphine and Rainelle Downing missing. Police showed up, found the bodies buried in the basement, and the game was up.

Confessions came quickly, perhaps because they thought Michigan was a safer bet punishment-wise (it didn’t have the death penalty). Their joint confession was a doozy – 73 or 76 pages of lurid details. Though they only admitted to a handful of murders, investigators suspected many more. Fernandez, ever the performer, later tried to retract his confession, claiming he did it to protect Beck. How romantic.

New York, however, had the electric chair, and the murder of Janet Fay provided the ticket. They were extradited and faced trial in the summer of 1949. It was a media frenzy. Front-page news, gavel-to-gavel coverage (well, the newspaper equivalent). The prosecution focused on Fay’s murder, armed with evidence like the trunk, bloodstains, and potentially those suspicious typed letters (though the typewriter detail remains slightly debated in terms of its courtroom impact).

The defense tried the “insanity” card, arguing diminished capacity. Predictably, it didn’t stick. The jury wasn’t buying it.

The press, in typical fashion, turned it into a spectacle. Martha Beck, in particular, was relentlessly mocked as “Big Martha,” her physical appearance and troubled past fodder for public ridicule. This caricature dehumanized her, simplifying a complex psychological profile into a grotesque monster, likely influencing public and jury perception. The trial became grim entertainment, making a nuanced understanding of their mental states nearly impossible amidst the sensationalism.

On August 18, 1949, the verdict came down: guilty. Four days later, the sentence: death by electrocution. Their confessions, while damning, also provided the fodder for the media circus. Fernandez’s last-ditch effort to appear noble by retracting his confession for Beck’s sake just added another layer to their deeply dysfunctional, all-consuming bond.

VI. The Final Act: Sing Sing Send-off

Raymond Fernandez and Martha Beck took their last walk on March 8, 1951, to the electric chair at Sing Sing prison. The user article attributes a dramatic quote to Fernandez upon arrest: “I’m no average killer! I have a way with women, a power over them.” While he certainly believed he had this power (thanks, Voodoo), the specific quote’s direct attribution to arresting officers isn’t strongly corroborated in contemporary reports.

In their final hours, their focus remained squarely on each other. Martha reportedly sent Raymond a love note. Contemporary news reports confirm they “vowed shortly before they died that they still loved each other.” Fernandez, when asked if he still loved Beck, reportedly replied, “Of course I do.” Beck’s reported last words: “I am a woman who has had a great love, and always will have it.” The user article offers more dramatic quotes (“Now I am ready to die!” etc.), which might be later embellishment, but the core sentiment of their twisted devotion seems consistent across accounts.

The user article claims Fernandez faltered walking to the chair and had to be dragged. Contemporary reports don’t corroborate this. Regarding Martha, the claim that she “barely fit” into the electric chair is noted, and some secondary sources/film trivia support that due to her size (around 200 pounds), she had to be seated on the armrests. While she was large, the “armrests” detail is one to approach with a grain of salt unless definitively sourced to primary documents.

The atmosphere in the execution chamber? According to the user article, it wasn’t sorrowful, but felt like justice served. This aligns with the contemporary report noting they “Neither expressed any remorse over the crimes.”

Their final declarations of love, however pathological, served as a defiant, dramatic closing statement, reinforcing the narrative of a love so powerful, so all-consuming, that it led them to kill and die together. It’s a morbid “love story” that continues to capture attention, a testament to the dark, destructive potential of human connection gone horribly wrong. They went out focusing on each other, a final, chilling affirmation of their bond forged in deceit and sealed in blood.

Bibliography

1. The Lonely Hearts Killers are executed | March 8, 1951 – History.com, accessed May 18, 2025, https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/march-8/the-lonely-hearts-killers-are-executed
2. Match Made in Hell: How the ‘Lonely Hearts’ Killers Seduced Their Prey with Newspaper Ads During Murderous Spree – People.com, accessed May 18, 2025, https://people.com/lonely-hearts-killers-raymond-fernandez-martha-beck-match-made-hell-8767599
3. Raymond Fernandez and Martha Beck – Wikipedia, accessed May 18, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raymond_Fernandez_and_Martha_Beck
4. CRIME: Big Martha | TIME, accessed May 18, 2025, https://time.com/archive/6785562/crime-big-martha/
5. “LONELY HEARTS” GO TO ELECTRIC CHAIR – Trove (Digitised contemporary newspaper report from The Canberra Times), accessed May 18, 2025, https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/50101734
6. Personal advertisement – Wikipedia, accessed May 18, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personal_advertisement
7. 2,947 Raymond Fernandez Photos & High Res Pictures – Getty Images (Contains police evidence photos), accessed May 18, 2025, https://www.gettyimages.com/photos/raymond-fernandez
8. 27 Janet Fay Photos & High Res Pictures – Getty Images (Contains police evidence photos), accessed May 18, 2025, https://www.gettyimages.com/photos/janet-fay