John E. Robinson: The First Internet Serial Killer Used Chat Rooms to Murder

1. John E. Robinson Case Dossier Abstract

Subject Identification: John Edward Robinson (DOB: December 27, 1943)

Operational Aliases: “Slavemaster,” “John Osborne,” “James Turner,” “B.J.”

Criminal Classification: Sexual Homicide Offender / Organized / Mixed Motivation (Financial/Sadistic)

Criminological Significance: Designated as the first known serial killer to utilize the Internet as a primary vehicle for victim acquisition, grooming, and entrapment.

Operational Timeline: 1984 – 2000

Confirmed Victims: 8 (Adjudicated); Investigative estimates place the number higher, potentially involving unrecovered remains in multiple jurisdictions.

Current Status: Incarcerated, Death Row (El Dorado Correctional Facility, Kansas); Serving consecutive life sentences without parole (Missouri).

1.1 Executive Profile Assessment

The investigative landscape of John Edward Robinson presents a distinct deviation from the traditional trajectory of serial predation observed in the 20th century. Standard profiles of sexual homicide offenders often depict individuals with marked social dysfunction, impulsive violence, or a history of disorganized behavior. Robinson, conversely, operated under the camouflage of extreme normalcy—a “mask of sanity” so effectively constructed that he navigated the upper echelons of suburban life while managing a complex infrastructure of enslavement and murder.

Robinson exemplifies the Organized/Mixed Motivation offender. His pathology is not driven solely by lust or solely by greed; rather, it is a synergistic fusion of the two. He viewed human beings, particularly women, as “biological assets” to be acquired, utilized for financial gain (through embezzlement, fraud, or theft of benefits), sexually exploited for sadistic gratification, and then liquidated when their utility expired or they became a liability.¹ This utilitarian approach to murder is more akin to corporate liquidation than the frenzied violence of a disorganized killer.

This report, compiled by Profiler Zero, deconstructs the mechanisms of Robinson’s pathology. It analyzes his transition from a white-collar fraudster in the 1960s to a lethal predator in the 1980s, and finally to his pioneering role as the “Slavemaster” of the digital age in the 1990s. Central to this analysis is the “International Council of Masters” (ICM), a fictional construct Robinson utilized to enforce psychological control, and the “barrels” found on his farm, which serve as the physical manifestation of his desire to possess and retain his victims even after death.²

Furthermore, this dossier examines the forensic breakdown of his digital footprint—the AOL chat logs, IP address tracking, and email forgeries—that ultimately dismantled his operation. It serves not only as a historical account but as a warning system for the modern digital environment, drawing direct parallels between Robinson’s primitive “catfishing” and contemporary threats such as sextortion, deepfake manipulation, and encrypted predation.⁴

2. Developmental History and the Psychogenesis of a Fraudster

To understand the predator who would eventually hunt in the digital ether, one must first understand the analog conman who preceded him. Robinson’s criminal evolution was not linear; it was a widening gyre of deceit that began with financial crimes and spiraled into bodily violation.

2.1 The Narcissistic Seed: Early Life (1943–1964)

Born in Cicero, Illinois, Robinson’s early life did not display the violent red flags often associated with the “Macdonald Triad” (enuresis, pyromania, zoosadism). Instead, his pathology manifested through Malignant Narcissism and Antisocial Personality Disorder (ASPD). He was an Eagle Scout, a distinction he would weaponize for the rest of his life to garner unearned trust. He attended Quigley Preparatory Seminary, ostensibly to become a priest. This interest in the priesthood is consistent with narcissistic profiles seeking positions of unimpeachable moral authority and access to vulnerable populations.¹

However, the facade cracked early. He was a poor student and a disciplinary problem, traits that contradicted the “perfectionist” image he sought to project. The disparity between his grandiose self-image and his actual achievements created a “narcissistic wound”—a psychological tension he sought to resolve through deception. If he could not earn status, he would fabricate it.

2.2 The “Man of the Year” Complex: White Collar Escalation (1966–1980)

Robinson’s entry into adulthood was marked by a sophisticated pattern of imposture.

• The X-Ray Technician Fraud (1966-1969): Robinson secured employment with Dr. Wallace Graham as an X-ray technician using forged credentials. This was not merely a job; it was a stage. He embezzled $33,000 from the practice, draining the accounts within six months. When caught, he received probation—a judicial leniency that reinforced his belief in his own invulnerability.¹
• The “Man of the Year” Delusion: Perhaps the most illustrative incident of his pathology occurred during his tenure at a community board. Robinson ordered stationery and forged letters from the executive director and the Mayor, inviting civic leaders to an awards luncheon honoring a “Man of the Year.” The recipient was to be Robinson himself. The award was entirely engineered by him. When the dignitaries saw the announcements in the newspaper, the fraud was exposed. This incident reveals the depth of his Grandiosity. He risked everything not for money, but for adulation. The need to be seen as important, benevolent, and superior was a hunger that financial theft alone could not sate.¹

2.3 The Utility of Humans

During this period (1970-1980), Robinson moved his family frequently between Kansas City and Chicago, violating probation with impunity. He worked for various companies (Mobile Oil, R.B. Jones Insurance, Guy’s Food), always ending in embezzlement.¹

• Insight: Robinson treated his employers and colleagues as resources to be mined. He learned that people are generally trusting, especially of a “church-going family man.” He refined the art of the “Trust Trap”—gaining intimacy (financial or professional) to exploit the victim. This skill set, honed in the boardroom, would later be transferred to the bedroom and the chat room. The leap from stealing a pension fund to stealing a human life is significant in law, but in Robinson’s psychology, it was merely an adjustment of the commodity being extracted.

3. The Analog Predator: The Equi-II Era (1984–1993)

By the mid-1980s, Robinson’s need for control escalated beyond the financial. He began to merge his fraud schemes with sexual domination. He established shell companies, most notably Equi-II, which posed as a management consulting firm but functioned as a front for his predatory activities.

3.1 Paula Godfrey: The Erasure of Identity (1984)

In 1984, Robinson hired 19-year-old Paula Godfrey for Equi-II. He sold her a narrative of corporate success, sending her for “training.” This was the Isolation Phase. He moved her out of her environment and into his control.

• The Disappearance: Godfrey vanished in September 1984.
• The Forgery Technique: To prevent a police investigation, Robinson forged a typewritten letter, signed by Godfrey, sent to her parents. It stated she was “OK” and wanted no contact. Because she was legal age (19), and the police had a “signed” letter, the missing persons case was closed.²
• Forensic Implication: This success taught Robinson a lethal lesson: Bureaucracy can be manipulated to cover murder. If he could control the paper trail—letters, contracts, bank accounts—he could control the narrative of the victim’s existence. Godfrey’s remains have never been found; she was effectively erased from the earth.

3.2 Lisa Stasi and the “Baby Broker” Scheme (1985)

The abduction of Lisa Stasi and her 4-month-old daughter, Tiffany, represents the apex of Robinson’s sociopathy during the analog era.

• The Lure: Posing as “John Osborne,” a philanthropist, Robinson approached Stasi at a battered women’s shelter in Kansas City. He targeted her vulnerability—a young, single mother in distress. He promised her job training and housing in Chicago.¹
• The Transaction: In January 1985, he moved Stasi and Tiffany to a hotel. Lisa Stasi was murdered shortly thereafter. Her body has never been found.
• The Ultimate Commodification: Robinson did not kill the infant. Instead, he treated Tiffany Stasi as a high-value asset. He contacted his brother, Donald Robinson, who was seeking to adopt. Robinson forged adoption papers, claiming the mother had committed suicide, and “gave” the baby to his brother. He charged his brother $5,500 in legal fees.⁷
• Psychological Analysis: This act is chillingly unique. Most serial killers view children of victims as liabilities to be discarded. Robinson viewed Tiffany as inventory. He monetized the murder of the mother by selling the child to his own family. For 15 years, Tiffany grew up as Heather Robinson, calling her mother’s killer “Uncle John.” This proximity—keeping the victim’s child within his own family orbit—demonstrates a supreme God Complex. He believed he had the power to grant life (to Heather) and death (to Lisa) with total impunity.

3.3 The Prison Interlude and the “Prison Librarian” (1987–1993)

Robinson was incarcerated for fraud from 1987 to 1993. Even behind bars, his predation continued. He groomed Beverly Bonner, the prison librarian.

• The Manipulation: He convinced Bonner to divorce her husband and cash out her assets. Upon his release, she moved to Kansas City to be with him.
• The Outcome: She became one of the bodies in the storage units. This demonstrates that Robinson’s “rehabilitation” period was simply a “recruitment” period. The correctional system failed to identify the lethal risk he posed because his convictions were “non-violent.” This classification error allowed a wolf to socialize with the staff.²

4. The Digital Hunting Ground: The First “Internet Serial Killer”

Upon his release in 1993, Robinson encountered a new technological frontier: The Internet. For a man who thrived on deception, false personas, and remote manipulation, the early web was a paradise. He is widely cited as the first serial killer to systematically use the internet to hunt.²

4.1 The “Slavemaster” Persona and the BDSM Community

Robinson frequented early online chat rooms (AOL, BDSM forums) using the handle “Slavemaster.”

• The Environment: The late 90s internet was anonymous and unregulated. Users were naive to the dangers of “catfishing” (a term that did not yet exist).
• The Strategy: Robinson targeted the BDSM (Bondage, Domination, Sadism, Masochism) community. He understood that in BDSM dynamics, submissives are often looking for a dominant partner to take control. He exploited this consensual dynamic to facilitate non-consensual harm.⁶
• The Lure: He did not present himself as a truck driver or a drifter. He posed as a wealthy, sophisticated, international businessman. He offered his victims not just sexual dominance, but financial security, travel, and a lifestyle of luxury. He screened for women who were financially struggling or emotionally vulnerable, using the promise of philanthropy as the bait.

4.2 The “International Council of Masters” (ICM)

To enforce control, Robinson fabricated a secret society called the “International Council of Masters.”

• The Myth: He told victims he was a high-ranking member of this elite, global organization. He claimed the Council monitored all “slaves” and that disobedience would be punished not just by him, but by the organization’s reach.¹
• Ritualistic Control: While not “occult” in a supernatural sense, this functioned as a secular cult. He created a mythology of omnipotence. If a victim thought about escaping, she had to fear the “Council.” This is a classic tactic of Coercive Control—isolating the victim within a fabricated reality where the abuser is all-powerful. It mirrors the tactics of intelligence agencies or organized crime, repurposed for sexual enslavement.³

4.3 The “Slave Contract”: A Legal Instrument of Enslavement

The defining signature of Robinson’s digital era was the Slave Contract. The most notorious example was signed by Izabela Lewicka.²

• The Document: A 115-item legalistic document.
• Key Clauses:
  • Total submission to the “Master’s” sexual and domestic demands.
  • Financial Control: The contract explicitly granted Robinson power of attorney over the victim’s bank accounts and assets.
  • Surrender of Agency: Clauses dictating when the victim could speak, eat, or sleep.
• Forensic Psychology: For Robinson, the signing of the contract was likely as gratifying as the murder itself. It validated his narcissism. He was not “stealing” their lives; they were “signing them over.” This legalism assuaged any residual guilt—in his mind, they agreed to become property. Furthermore, the financial clauses prove the Mixed Motivation: even in his sexual fantasies, he was securing access to their money.

4.4 Victimology of the Digital Age

Sheila and Debbie Faith (1994):

• The Profile: Sheila Faith was a 45-year-old widow; her daughter Debbie, 15, had spina bifida and used a wheelchair.
• The Lure: Robinson, the “philanthropist,” promised to pay for Debbie’s expensive medical care and provide them a home.
• The Reality: He moved them to Kansas City and murdered them. He kept their bodies in storage and continued to cash their Social Security and disability checks for six years. The murder of a disabled child for a monthly check highlights the absolute moral vacuum at the center of Robinson’s psyche.²

Izabela Lewicka (1999):

• The Profile: A 21-year-old Polish immigrant and Purdue University student.
• The Lure: A “marriage” proposal. Robinson even took her to get a marriage license (despite being already married) to prove his intent.
• The Outcome: She signed the slave contract and was never seen again. Her body was found in a barrel on his farm.

Suzette Trouten (2000):

• The Profile: A 27-year-old nurse from Michigan.
• The Lure: Travel and a submissive relationship.
• The Breakdown: Trouten was close to her family. When she vanished, Robinson sent forged letters to her mother. However, the letters were “uncharacteristically free of typographical errors” and lacked Suzette’s voice.⁶ This forensic linguistics error—Robinson’s inability to mimic the specific vernacular of his victim—was a crack in the dam that led to the investigation.

5. Crime Scene Deconstruction: The Barrels and The Storage

In June 2000, the investigation culminated in a series of raids that exposed the physical reality of Robinson’s “collection.” The trigger was not a murder charge, but a sexual battery complaint and a theft charge involving stolen sex toys.² This aligns with the historical trend where high-profile killers are often tripped up by minor infractions (e.g., Al Capone’s taxes, Ted Bundy’s traffic stop).

5.1 The La Cygne Farm (Kansas)

On Robinson’s property in Linn County, Kansas, investigators located two 85-pound chemical drums.

• Contents: The decomposing remains of Izabela Lewicka and Suzette Trouten.
• Forensic Analysis: The use of industrial chemical drums indicates a desire for sanitized containment. Robinson did not bury the bodies in the dirt; he packed them in manufactured containers. This suggests he viewed the bodies as hazardous waste or inventory to be stored rather than human remains to be interred. The barrels were portable, implying he wanted the option to move his “assets” if necessary.

5.2 The Raymore Storage Units (Missouri)

Simultaneously, investigators searched storage units rented by Robinson in Missouri. They found three more barrels.

• Contents: The remains of Beverly Bonner, Sheila Faith, and Debbie Faith.
• Temporal Significance: Some of these bodies had been stored for years (Faiths disappeared in 1994; discovered in 2000).
• The Psychology of Hoarding: Robinson paid monthly rent to house these corpses. He could have disposed of them in a river or a landfill. By keeping them, he engaged in “Trophy Retention” on a macro scale. He possessed them completely. As long as he paid the rent, he owned the women. This aligns with the “Slavemaster” persona—a master never releases a slave, even in death.⁸

5.3 Digital Forensics: The Smoking Gun

The physical evidence was corroborated by what was, at the time, cutting-edge digital forensics.

• IP Address Tracking: Investigators subpoenaed America Online (AOL) for the records of “Slavemaster.” They matched the IP addresses of emails sent to victims’ families (claiming they were “traveling” or “happy”) to Robinson’s home connection. In 2000, this was novel evidence. It dismantled his alibi that the women had left voluntarily.¹⁰
• The Hard Drives: Police seized five computers. The analysis revealed the slave contracts, the forged letters, and the chat logs. This digital crime scene was as bloody as the physical one, documenting the grooming process in real-time.

6. Investigative and Judicial Critique

6.1 The Failures of the 1980s: Jurisdictional Blindness

The investigations into Paula Godfrey and Lisa Stasi in the mid-80s failed due to Jurisdictional Fragmentation. Robinson moved victims across state lines (Kansas to Missouri to Illinois). Local police agencies did not share databases. When Robinson produced a “signed letter” from Godfrey, the Overland Park police closed the case, lacking the forensic tools (or the cynicism) to verify the signature or the typewriter ballistics. Robinson exploited the “benefit of the doubt” afforded to a white male business owner.⁶

6.2 The Trial and “Juror 39”

Robinson was tried in Kansas in 2002 for the murders of Stasi, Trouten, and Lewicka.

• The Verdict: Guilty. Sentenced to Death.
• The Plea: To avoid a second death penalty trial in Missouri, he pleaded guilty to the five murders there, receiving life without parole.
• The Juror 39 Controversy: Appeals have heavily focused on “Juror 39,” who admitted during voir dire that she leaned toward guilt but could be swayed. The defense argued this denied Robinson an impartial jury. The Kansas Supreme Court upheld the conviction, ruling that the juror’s eventual affirmation of neutrality was sufficient. This highlights the high threshold for overturning convictions based on jury selection in the face of overwhelming physical evidence.¹²

6.3 Psychiatric Testimony

During the penalty phase, the defense attempted to present mitigation evidence regarding Robinson’s mental state. However, Robinson has consistently refused to fit the mold of the “insane” offender. He is hyper-rational.

• The Diagnosis: Expert testimony and behavioral analysis confirm Antisocial Personality Disorder and Sexual Sadism. There is no evidence of psychosis (hallucinations, breaks with reality). Robinson knew exactly what he was doing; he simply did not care. His “insanity” was moral, not cognitive.¹

7. Lingering Questions and The “Missing”

7.1 The Unidentified Victims

Robinson is confirmed to have killed 8 women. However, he was active for nearly 20 years.

• Catherine Clampitt (1987): An employee of Equi-II who vanished. She is a suspected victim, but her body has never been found.
• The Iowa Body: In 2006, a body was found in Iowa, where Robinson did business. Police suspect a link, but no DNA match has been confirmed.²
• The Silence: Robinson maintains silence regarding other victims. As one investigator noted, “It’s the last control he’s got.” By withholding the locations of other bodies, he continues to torture the families of the missing.⁶

7.2 The Family Question

How did his family—wife Nancy and his children—not know?

• Willful Blindness: Robinson was a tyrant at home. He compartmentalized his life strictly. The “locked room” or the “business trip” was not to be questioned. This dynamic of domestic terror often creates a circle of silence where family members subconsciously avoid the truth to ensure their own survival.²

8. Modern Parallels: The Legacy of the Slavemaster

John Robinson’s case was a prophecy. He foreshadowed the dangers that are now endemic to the digital experience.

8.1 From “Slavemaster” to “Sextortion”

Robinson used the primitive internet to find victims. Today, predators use Sextortion—coercing victims into providing sexual images and then blackmailing them. Robinson’s “Slave Contract” was an analog version of this. He gathered compromising information (financial and sexual) to ensure the victim could never go to the police. The mechanic is identical; only the speed of transmission has changed.⁵

8.2 The “Catfish” Evolution

Robinson was the original Catfish. He proved that a user could curate a digital avatar (wealthy, powerful, kind) that completely overrode their physical reality (aging, thief, murderer). Modern “Romance Scams” and “Pig Butchering” scams use the exact script Robinson wrote in 1995: Build trust, promise financial freedom, isolate the victim, and extract the asset.¹⁴

8.3 Encryption and Safety

In 2000, police could subpoena AOL and get the chat logs. Today, with End-to-End Encryption (Signal, Telegram, WhatsApp), a predator like Robinson could operate with much higher security. If Robinson were active today, the “digital smoking gun” might be locked behind encryption keys that law enforcement cannot break. This presents a terrifying evolution in the cat-and-mouse game of cyber-investigation.⁴

9. Conclusion: The Banality of Evil in the Digital Age

John Edward Robinson was not a monster who lived under a bridge. He was a monster who lived in the suburbs, served on community boards, and dialed into the internet just like millions of other Americans. He weaponized the mundane tools of modern life: the contract, the storage unit, the chat room.

His legacy is the loss of innocence for the internet. He proved that the screen is not a barrier; it is a window. Through that window, he reached out and pulled women into a darkness from which they never returned. The “Barrels” stand as a permanent monument to his commodification of human life—a reminder that for the psychopath, people are merely inventory to be stored until they expire.

The hunt for John Robinson was the first major victory of digital forensics, but it was also a warning. The “Slavemaster” is in prison, but the hunting ground he helped pioneer is now open to the world.

Table 1: Confirmed and Suspected Victim Timeline

Table 2: Forensic Pivot Points in the Investigation

Table 3: Psychological Triad of the Offender

Works cited

1. John Edward Robinson Sr. – New Page 1 – Radford University, accessed December 8, 2025, https://maamodt.asp.radford.edu/Psyc%20405/serial%20killers/Robinson,%20John%20Edward%20-%202005.pdf
2. The Internet’s First Serial Killer: John Edward Robinson, The ‘Internet Slavemaster’ | Investigation Discovery, accessed December 8, 2025, https://www.investigationdiscovery.com/crimefeed/serial-killer/the-internets-first-serial-killer-john-edward-robinson-the-internet-slavemaster
3. Missing and Murdered in the Midwest: John Robinson Part 2 Hunting on the Internet, accessed December 8, 2025, https://www.wqad.com/article/syndication/podcasts/missing-and-murdered-in-the-midwest-john-robinson-part-two/526-362f4fc4-297e-4b60-b779-8518046d674d
4. An e-SOS for Cyberspace – Harvard Law School Journals, accessed December 8, 2025, https://journals.law.harvard.edu/ilj/wp-content/uploads/sites/84/2011/07/HILJ_52-2_Hollis1.pdf
5. Sextortion: Cybersecurity, teenagers, and remote sexual assault – Brookings Institution, accessed December 8, 2025, https://www.brookings.edu/articles/sextortion-cybersecurity-teenagers-and-remote-sexual-assault/
6. John Edward Robinson – Wikipedia, accessed December 8, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Edward_Robinson
7. John Robinson Today: Inside the Serial Killer’s Life in Prison – Biography, accessed December 8, 2025, https://www.biography.com/crime/a64969943/john-robinson-now-heather-robinson-kidnapping
8. Missing and Murdered in the Midwest: John Robinson Part 3, The Internet’s First Serial Killer, accessed December 8, 2025, https://www.wqad.com/article/syndication/podcasts/missing-and-murdered-in-the-midwest-john-robinson-the-internets-first-serial-killer-part-3/526-4998e9a0-7f58-4547-9415-fbe181b3d090
9. Cyber Ripper ‘killed to feed adoption racket’ | Technology – The Guardian, accessed December 8, 2025, https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2000/sep/03/internetnews.theobserver
10. Computer Forensics: The Issues and Current Books in the Field, accessed December 8, 2025, https://www.garykessler.net/library/computer_forensics_books.html
11. Baltimore Police Department – Wikipedia, accessed December 8, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baltimore_Police_Department
12. Court considers appeal from serial killer John Robinson – YouTube, accessed December 8, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gljiwiOTg0o
13. State v. Robinson – Kansas Supreme Court Decisions – Justia Law, accessed December 8, 2025, https://law.justia.com/cases/kansas/supreme-court/2017/110040.html
14. The Internet’s First Serial Killer – John Edward Robinson – Apple Podcasts, accessed December 8, 2025, https://podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/the-internets-first-serial-killer-john-edward-robinson/id1816028707?i=1000719995599
15. Chat Control or Child Protection – arXiv, accessed December 8, 2025, https://arxiv.org/pdf/2210.08958